Back to article list
SocietyVerifiedUnited States

United States

English original

Florida Supreme Court limits automatic transfer of attorney-fee obligations

The Florida Supreme Court returned an easement dispute to the federal appeals court, ruling that an old agreement's legal-fees clause does not automatically bind later owners. The earlier $40,000 trespass award remains intact.

AI-generated illustrative topic photo of a chain-link gate across a narrow gravel access lane between homes and wooden fences.
AI-generated illustrative topic photo for a story about land-use easements and contractual obligations. It does not depict the disputed property or the reported events.

The Florida Supreme Court ruled in an October 29, 2026, opinion that a contractual requirement for the losing party to pay the winner's attorney fees does not automatically extend to later property owners. The court was answering a question referred by the US Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit.

An easement allows someone to use another person's property for a specific purpose without owning it. The agreement in this dispute permitted a telecommunications company and its successors to use a defined portion of neighboring land.

The dispute arose in 2020 when Crown Castle excavated outside the authorized easement on RJI's property and installed underground fiber-optic cables. RJI sued in the US District Court for the Southern District of Florida, alleging trespass and breach of the easement agreement, among other claims.

The district court found that Crown Castle had exceeded the authorized boundaries. A jury then awarded RJI $1 for breach of the agreement and $40,000 for trespass after a six-day damages trial. It awarded no punitive damages.

The Florida Supreme Court explained that an obligation must directly concern the land's use or enjoyment to continue automatically after a sale. The attorney-fees clause failed that test because it allocated litigation expenses rather than governing how the property could be used or maintained.

The matter returns to the federal appeals court for further proceedings. The Florida Supreme Court's decision does not cancel RJI's earlier $40,000 trespass award.