Back to article list
SocietyVerifiedKorea

Korea

Korean originalTranslated

Ulsan University Hospital funeral hall cooks lose direct-employment appeal

The Busan High Court's First Civil Division in Ulsan dismissed all appeals by four plaintiffs, including dietitians and cooks employed by a service contractor, in a case seeking recognition of employee status and other relief.

Rice, soup, meat and vegetable side dishes on an indoor table, with condolence wreaths and a mourning room in the background.
Reference photo of a funeral hall meal. A direct connection to the hospital or the plaintiffs mentioned in the article has not been established.

The Busan High Court's First Civil Division in Ulsan recently dismissed all appeals by four plaintiffs, including company-employed dietitians and cooks, in a case seeking recognition of employee status and other relief.

The plaintiffs continued in employment as service contractors changed, preparing food and managing ingredients at Ulsan University Hospital's funeral hall kitchen. They sought direct employment, arguing that the hospital exercised authority over work instructions, attendance and hiring, and that the cooking work was substantively integrated into its funeral hall business, making the arrangement worker dispatch.

Worker dispatch separates the company employing the workers from the user company directing their work; under the law governing dispatched workers, the user employer must employ them directly when certain grounds arise, such as a breach of statutory dispatch-duration limits. Contracting is an arrangement in which the contractor performs work independently and takes responsibility for the result; working at the principal's premises generally does not constitute worker dispatch if the principal does not directly instruct or supervise the workers.

The court found insufficient evidence that the hospital exercised substantial direction or control. It considered the funeral director's delivery of order slips to the kitchen a possible provision of information needed to complete the contracted work, and found that the workers themselves decided shift arrangements, early starts and overtime.

The court also rejected the argument that cooking was substantively integrated into the hospital's business. Among the factors it considered was that cooking facilities are not among the mandatory funeral hall facilities specified under the Act on Funeral Services.

The court did not regard continued employment when service contractors changed as a result of the hospital's direct workforce management. This was because a collective agreement with the union made continued employment a condition for selecting a new contractor; the court also interpreted the hospital's payment for ingredients and involvement in ordering and inspection as the provision of ingredients and receipt of usage and inventory reports under the service contract.