United States
English original
Florida appeals court orders fresh review of divorce support and parenting
The ruling requires a new analysis of income and parental responsibility; it does not automatically award alimony or require equal parenting time.

Florida's Fourth District Court of Appeal ordered a fresh review of alimony, child support and parenting arrangements in a Broward County divorce case. It found that the trial court had failed to make legally required findings before denying the wife's alimony request and awarding the husband all parenting time and broad decision-making authority.
The ruling does not automatically entitle the wife to alimony or require equal parenting time. The trial court must redo its analysis using net incomes, evidence-supported income figures and proper parental-responsibility standards. The denial of the wife's attorney's fees and costs was affirmed.
On alimony, the Fourth District found that the trial court had omitted required findings before considering statutory factors. It also found that the judge improperly relied on gross income assigned to the wife rather than conducting the necessary net-income analysis.
A school representative testified that a teacher with a master's degree earned $54,000, more than the wife's last teaching salary. But no qualifying teaching position was shown to be available. The appellate court therefore found insufficient evidence for assigning her that $54,000 salary.
On parenting, the Fourth District said unlimited decision-making authority for one parent effectively nullified shared parental responsibility. It explained that Florida law permits ultimate authority over specific issues on which parents cannot agree, rather than control over every area of a child's life.
The appellate court also held that a child's best interests alone cannot justify sole parental responsibility: the judge must determine whether shared responsibility would harm the child. Because the original judgment contained no such finding, the parenting ruling was reversed.